Craig, Meyerhold & Modernism
CRAIG AND MEYERHOLD: THE THEATRE AND MODERNISM
From the middle of the nineteenth century – and arguably less militantly long before – the visual arts were in a state of rapidly evolving redefinition, passing through a positive paroxysm of -isms, each one more radically challenging the fundamental concepts of what drawing, painting, etching and sculpture might be. This phenomenon crystallised at the beginning of the twentieth century into something called Modernism, a notion under whose banner many disparate figures could rally. It was inevitable that practitioners of other arts, notably music and dance, would wish to make common cause with the fine arts and their heroic and epic explorations of the boundaries of expression. The theatre, widely considered an impure, not to say a bastard, art, was slower to embrace the sort of radicalism that seemed to come easily to the Fine Artists. But it was not standing still.
The theatre is always in a state of evolution. Changes in theatrical fashion, changes in theatrical architecture, the development of new technology, alterations in the political climate, changes, perhaps, in human nature and, most markedly, changes in taste, mean that the theatre is under constant pressure to keep abreast of the times. Occasionally – very occasionally – it seeks to be the instrument of change itself, but generally speaking, its survival depends on embracing, or at the very least expressing, the zeitgeist. From Greek and Roman times, in other words from the birth of theatre as we understand it in the West, it has had a complex relationship with authority, never more so than in the early twentieth century; under totalitarian regimes, it easily becomes another means of controlling the populace.
Towards the end of the nineteenth century, with the relentless growth of capitalism and its attendant woes across the globe, there was a significant shift in playhouses away from melodrama towards social realism, necessitating a modification of the flamboyant theatricality that had predominated through most of the century under the aegis of actor-managers, their productions contrived to showcase their personal charisma. In Britain, as throughout the West, a new wave of socially-informed writing, inspired by Ibsen and Strindberg and later Chekhov, began to take hold. Principal among those fiercely resisting this development was Henry Irving, (1838-1905), the most famous actor-manager in the English-speaking world of his time, the first actor to be knighted, beloved of audiences on both sides of the Atlantic and endorsed by the monarchy. His life’s work had been to make the theatre morally respectable, historically informed, physically picturesque and sumptuously escapist. It is thus somewhat ironic that the most articulate and fiery mouthpiece of radical theatrical avant-gardisme in Britain, with an influence rapidly spreading across the globe, should have sprung from within his own ranks in the striking person of Edward Gordon Craig, (1872 – 1966), who, as the son of Irving’s co-star, Ellen Terry, had grown up in and around the Lyceum Theatre in London and travelled with the company on tour. From boyhood, he watched Irving and Terry from the wings, eventually, from the age of seventeen, acting with the man universally referred to as the Guv’nor, whom he loved as a man and idolised as an actor.
Later Craig worked without notable success as an actor in provincial repertory theatres, quitting the profession in 1897, aged twenty-five. He was a gifted draughtsman and illustrator, who trained under the pioneering graphic designers James Pryde and William Nicolson, and had begun, from an early age, to imagine a stagecraft radically different from Irving’s – or anyone else’s. His designs for an imaginary theatre were the antithesis of the sort of pageant-like spectacle favoured at the Lyceum and indeed across the country, but were equally antithetical to the increasingly dominant enthusiasm for scrupulously realistic staging as represented by the fanatically detailed work of André Antoine’s Théâtre Libre in Paris and the royally-sponsored Saxe-Meiningen Theatre under its artistic director, Ludwig Chronegk, which, after astounding Europe and Britain with its verismo, inspired many imitators. Craig rejected both the literal and the decorative. His earliest designs, from the 1890’s, suggest a distillation of landscape, a reduction of its elements into a quintessence. He makes great use of the height, the breadth and the width of the space; these are environments rather than locations. Great colonnades tower above the action, rectangular blocks, like skyscrapers, sometimes seem to have their roots in the soil, at other times simply loom massively, as the flames threaten to engulf them; staircases embedded in rocks wend their way up to invisible fortresses; a great bridge arches over the stage. There is nowhere for the actors to hide and no opportunities for the stage manager (or stage director, as Craig was accustomed to call him, though stage dictator might have been a more precise description) to embellish the action. Instead there is a huge intensification of expression, demanding immense focus. In a Craig design, the actors are tiny figures set in a huge universe of space: this is a dream theatre, created for dream actors. Who were they, where would they come from, these exceptional artists, this race of Thespian Titans who would not be overwhelmed by the vast spaces around them?
Here another, hugely influential, aspect of Craig’s vision of the theatre comes into play. If his designs were inspiring, his written texts on the subject of the actor were positively incendiary. In dialogues, in essays, in editorials in his widely circulated magazine The Mask, he described a kind of acting superman, heroically unconcerned with psychology or character. He imagined, without specifying exactly when or where such a phenomenon might have existed, a kind of ur-actor, hugely expressive, focussed on simply being. Except, he said, that there was within living memory one shining example of what an actor could be: Henry Irving. To many of his critics, this was preposterous. For almost all theatrical progressives, Irving had been a laughing stock, absurdly mannered. “Nature has done very little to make an actor of him,” wrote Henry James. “His face is not dramatic, it is the face of…anything other than a possible Hamlet or Othello. His figure is of the same cast, and his voice…is apparently wholly unavailable for the purposes of declamation.” Craig saw something else: “The very nearest approach that has ever been to the ideal actor, with his brain commanding his nature, has been Henry Irving…procure all the pictures, photographs, drawings you can of him, and try to read what is there. To begin with you will find a mask…I would say that the face of Irving was the connecting link between the spasmodic and ridiculous expression of the human face as used by the theatres of the last few centuries, and the masks which will be used in place of the human face in the near future.”
Clearly Craig, given these sentiments, was by no means embracing Modernism. On the contrary, he was trying to wind the clock back to a nobler and truer (though unspecified) past, when actors, eschewing impersonation, were able to work objectively on their performances. “The intellect would bring both itself and the emotions to so fine a sense of reason,” he wrote in Artists of the Theatre of Future (1908) “that the work would never boil to the bubbling point with its restless exhibition of activity but would create that perfect moderate heat which it would know how to keep temperate. The perfect actor would be he whose brain could conceive and could show us the perfect symbols of all which his nature contains.” Here, he appears to be reaching towards an Oriental conception of the theatre and of acting, just as his graphic work distils the physical world into its essential elements. Crucial to his conception is the idea of Beauty, invariably capitalised, betrayed, as he sees it, by realism, or rather, Realism. In the 1913 Foreword to the prospectus for the school he founded in Florence, he starts ringingly with a salvo against “the modern Realistic Theatre,” which, he says, “forgetful of all the Laws of Art, sets out to reflect the times. It reflects a small particle of the times, it drags back a curtain and exposes to our view an agitated caricature of Man and his Life, a figure gross in its attitude and hideous to look upon.” This, he says, is a betrayal of art: “It has never been the purpose of art to reflect and make uglier the ugliness of things, but to transform and make the already beautiful more beautiful and, in following this purpose, art shields us with sweet influences from the dark sorrows of our weakness.”
This is a remarkable statement of artistic conservatism from a man held, then and now, to be a revolutionary. It’s worth noting that it was written a year before the world was engulfed in a war which shattered any such Olympian notions of life and art. “The modern Realistic Theatre stirs up in the people the restlessness which is the enemy of all things,” he asserts. Decrying Realism as “a Revolt against the very Laws of the Art of the Theatre” he describes it as “a threat against the well-ordered life of the Citizen.” Luridly characterising its manifestations – “the gloomy expressions, the shuffling movements – the dark and closed in scenes – the spasmodic exclamations of the actors – the strange muffled atmosphere – ” he contends that all these things lead to “one sinister impression. Alas! All this is false and unworthy of the theatre… as an institution of the realm and as an Art.” Both in artistic aesthetic and political intent, this vision of the theatre would have come very comfortably from the pen of a Soviet censor: accent the positive. The assault on the theatre as it exists is comprehensive: “Among the evils which The Mask attacks…are Realism, Vulgarity, Commercialism and the trade spirit, Pedantry, Theatricalism, the aggressive personality of the actor, the star system, badly built theatres, the invasion of the theatre by other artists, the representation of ugliness, the acceptance of mere “effectiveness” as substitute for thoroughness in all branches of the profession, the selfish apathy and cowardice which would oppose all progress or reform lest it should militate against personal prosperity and personal ease.”
Elsewhere in the same Prospectus, Craig’s supporters are equally forthright in their insistence on him as the fons et origo of all that is true in the art of the theatre: in a page headed THE IDEAL THEATRE they ringingly state that “We believe that there is no Ideal Theatre except that which has sprung from the imagination of Gordon Craig...there have been thousands of other Theatres. They have all failed, one and all.” The writer (very probably Craig himself) notes that a recent banquet in his honour “was something more than a triumph of personality that they assembled to celebrate; it was public recognition and advocacy of a principle.”
Others pay tribute to Craig in similar cult-like terms. In the transcript of speeches from the banquet, the painter and writer John Rothenstein, later Principal of the Royal College of Art, hails Craig’s achievements, citing his productions – The Masque of Love, Dido and Aeneas, Bethlehem – and the plays he mounted for his mother, Ellen Terry (present at the banquet): Much Ado About Nothing and The Vikings at Helgeland. “Here,” said Rothenstein, “was a new and wonderful thing – that the theatre should suddenly give us that unity which until then we believed possible only in the more generally recognised arts of painting, music, sculpture and architecture…those of us who read The Mask…know how ceaselessly Craig has toiled to get to the root, hidden beneath the ground, of theatrical canons. That they lie entwined among the roots of life itself he has long since discovered. His aim, then, is clear. The Theatre exists to interpret life…life not in the accidental sense in which most people conceive it, but that essence through which all things are made manifest.” It was this vision of the theatre, this radical ideal, that had already inspired theatre practitioners over Europe, and even, provocatively asserts another contributor to the Prospectus, “imitators such as Professor Max Reinhardt.” In 1913, Reinhardt was already established as one of the great innovators of the German stage, his spectacular production of The Miracle, which had played in London in 1911, a huge international success. But it is arguable that Craig’s first brief but provocative book, On the Art of the Theatre, which laid out his theatrical philosophy in the form of a Socratic dialogue, had made him the hero and principal spokesman of theatrical progressivism. In it, he asserted the supremacy of the director, which naturally endeared him to a generation of would-be directors; he also challenged the very idea of playwrights. Writing for the theatre, he insisted, must not be literary and word-bound: it is simply an occasion for action and inner connection. He draws a distinction between a dramatic poem and a drama: “gesture is necessary to a drama,” he says, “and it is useless to a dramatic poem.” The father of the dramatist, he says, is not dramatic poet: it is the dancer. “The first dramatist knew that when he and his fellows appeared in front of them the audience would be more eager to see what he would do rather than to hear what he might say.” And he casually floated the idea that the perfect prototype of the actor was the marionette.
The modest success of his theatrical productions in England had led neither to offers of work or any but the most meagre of financial rewards and in 1904, encouraged by the European reaction to the book – which had rapidly gone into first a second then a Third Edition and been translated into French, Russian and Japanese – he moved to Europe. At first he settled in Weimar in Germany, where his host was Count Harry Kessler “the Red Count,” a highly sophisticated intellectual with a keen eye for the avant-garde, who set out to reproduce the artistic glories of Goethe’s time at the Court. Together he and Craig would transform the theatre. Craig found living under a Grand Duke, supported by an aristocratic patron of exquisite taste and probing intellect highly congenial, but Kessler’s tenure as arbiter elegantiarum in Weimar was short-lived; the brief triumph of liberalism – with which Craig had little sympathy – in pre-First World War Weimar was already faltering. The Red Count’s progressive taste in art, which included Cézanne, Renoir and Van Gogh, was starkly at odds with Craig’s inspiration in Renaissance and Ancient Greek modes; moreover, any attempts on Kessler’s part to facilitate Craig’s employment foundered on the Englishman’s insistence on absolute control over every single aspect of the production. Thus Kessler’s attempts to facilitate a collaboration on a possible Macbeth or Hamlet with Max Reinhardt’s Berlin company came to naught. The one tangible result of Craig’s association with Kessler was the publication for the latter’s Cranach Press of a series of designs for Hamlet, an exquisite volume which could reasonably be described as the greatest single achievement of Craig’s long career.
It was indeed a production of that same play that stands, with its flaws, his most ambitious work in the theatre. The play had haunted Craig from the time he first saw Irving perform the title role. He had performed the part himself (wearing Irving’s costume) in the provinces, to his own great dissatisfaction; indeed, the principal reason he gave up acting was his disappointment in himself as Hamlet. Thereafter he set his heart on directing the play. His finally doing so was a side-product of his tumultuous love affair with Isadora Duncan. Duncan was the toast of Europe, where she toured extensively, astounding audiences with her free-form dancing. Her work followed no formulas: it was freely expressive, her garments flowing, her feet bare. An electrifying performer, she cast aside all the conventions of classical dancing. For her contemporaries, it was held to be the acme of modernity, but for her, inspiration, came, as it did for Craig, from the simplicity and directness of the ancient world; her garments and indeed her movements were the result of her close study of the urns and bas-reliefs of Ancient Greece and Rome she come upon at the British Museum. Her Modernism and Craig’s were thus closely aligned. Indeed, Craig’s biographer, his son Edward, suggests that “through her he was to discover the final ingredient necessary to the formula that was to be the basis of all [his] future ideas for the theatre” – specifically, his conviction that dance must be the underlying element of the actor’s performance. Later he was to write about Irving’s fundamentally terpsichorean approach – a non-naturalistic, unpsychological physicalisation of deep inner characteristics.
As he stepped upon the boards of his theatre, at rehearsal, something was added to the walk – a consciousness…the ordinary life was being put away; something was coming into his blood; he could not feel the same as when on the paving stones of Bond Street…it wasn’t walking. It was dancing! In dancing his role, Irving went to the extreme limits available to a nineteenth-century actor, of preserving the last tingle of the mighty Greek tradition…he danced, he did not walk – he sang, he by no means only spoke. He was essentially artificial in distinction to being merely natural…
Astonishingly, the man who wrote that is the man Isadora Duncan chose to introduce to Konstantin Stanislavsky, co-founder of the Moscow Art Theatre, already internationally famous as the High Priest of psychological realism. She knew that Stanislavsky, already evolving what became known as his System, was seeking a way of expanding the expressive power of his actors. “He belongs not only to his country, but to the whole world,” she told the Russian, “and he must live where his genius will have the best chance to display itself, when working conditions and the general atmosphere will be best fitted to his needs. His place is in your Art Theatre.” Craig and he duly met. Stanislavsky, always powerfully moved by finding himself in the presence of an artist – as he had done with Duncan – immediately invited him to Moscow and the great adventure, spread over several years, began.
From the beginning, Craig was given every opportunity to put his long-gestated ideas into effect. For the first time in his career as a stage manager (as he described himself) his ideas were embraced without qualification. He found to his astonishment that Stanislavsky had an even lower opinion of actors’ creativity than his, but at the beginning of the process, at the end of 1909, his entire attention was focussed on the giant moveable screens – 18 foot high – that were the central element of his design. This new technique seemed to be both practical and versatile, enabling scenes to be changed, he assured the Russians, in a trice. Early on in this process, the screens proved hard to move, and at one rehearsal an alarming accident occurred when a screen fell very heavily on the stage hands pushing, whereat Stanislavsky prohibited them from being moved, thus collapsing a central strut of Craig’s vision. He himself was on holiday when it happened, already bored by the mere thought of the dreary day-to-day reality of mounting a play. “I want time to study the Theatre,” he wrote to a friend. “I do not want to waste time producing plays – for that is vanity – expensive – unsatisfying – comic…this Hamlet production in Russia is wasting my time. I seek to know. I do not seek a position or success – and this work in Moscow is old work. I have passed it all – gone on to places where I have really seen something – a glimpse of something wonderful. And now I have to return and work at this nothing – this “producing Hamlet.”
In truth, he did precious little “producing Hamlet.” The production finally opened, thanks to the tireless work of the MAT team, with some success. “Mr Craig,” said the London Times, “has the singular power of carrying the spiritual significance of words and dramatic situations beyond the actor to the scene in which he moves. By the simplest of means he is able in some mysterious way to evoke almost any sensation of time or space, the scenes in themselves even suggesting variations of human emotion.” The anonymous reviewer seems to have hit on the essential character of Craig’s genius: he was a magician, conjuring images and moods in shapes, in light and in colour. In that regard, he may be said to be a manifestation, not of modernism at all, but of a very old thaumaturgical tradition, immediately recognisable to .Russians as that of the charlatan, the showman.
When he finally arrived before the opening of Hamlet, he had behaved disgracefully, abusing colleagues who had worked tirelessly to realise his often highly impractical concepts. As so often, he left behind him a trail of disappointed colleagues he had charmed and stimulated and recruited to his cause, only to dump them, bewildered, when they had, as he saw it, failed him. They all continued to support the production; even when they felt bitter towards him as a man, they continued to think of him as a genius. Indeed, Living Theatre, the same remarkable 1913 Prospectus for Craig’s school in Florence from which I have extensively quoted includes tributes to Craig from The Hungarian Theatre, The French Theatre and even The British Theatre, and carries two from Russia, the first a carefully worded one from Stanislavsky: “Please accept the sincerest congratulations of your Russian friends and admirers, who were fortunate enough to witness the realisation of your artistic ambitions and have shared the joys and disappointments which you felt so keenly in a foreign country…may you have further perseverance to fulfil your mission of beauty…the beauty which is too subtle and strange to be appreciated immediately by the throng of ordinary theatregoers, over which your genius hovers.” The secretary of the Moscow Art Theatre writes: “Mr Gordon Craig was, I fear, regarded by a good many of you some years ago as an alchemist searching for a philosopher’s stone that would turn everything to gold. It was the privilege of the Moscow Art Theatre to provide that alchemist with the materials by which the philosopher’s stone can be found.” He further looks forward to Hamlet opening in St Petersburg and London, openings which, alas, were never to happen.
It was the last theatrical event of any significance with which he was involved, but his influence remained strong, less in detail, more in general influence. In the twentieth century, his contemporary and friend, the Swiss director-designer Adolphe Appia, who shared Craig’s vision of sculpted light and a sculpted stage, had immense and specific influence in the opera house of the twentieth century, Craig less so. But he was not forgotten. A young Peter Brook befriended him in the 1950’s (Craig lived on to 1966, dying at the age of 94), declaring in print that his theories “have reminded the theatre that its eternal criteria are simplicity, beauty and truth.” Within 10 years Brook had transferred his allegiances to Antonin Artaud, in whose honour he devised a Theatre of Cruelty season for the Royal Shakespeare Company.
As it happens Craig returned to Russia in 1935, where he was greeted by (and photographed with) actors and workers from the Moscow Art Theatre and a handful of the leading lights of the Soviet Theatre, including Alexander Tairov and Vsevolod Meyerhold. Yevgeny Vakhtangov, the director whose work he had so admired, was long dead. Tairov lived on to a distinguished old age. A mere 5 years after the jolly photoshoot, Meyerhold was destined to be arrested, tortured and finally shot dead.
His career, so brutally extinguished, was extraordinary even by the standards of the 20th century Russian Theatre which, out of modest activity in the last third of the 19th century, had exploded into a powerhouse of theatrical experiment and innovation. Often at its centre, sometimes confined to the periphery, was Meyerhold, a powerhouse of ideas and fearless exploration of the possibilities of the theatre. Unlike Craig, he no background in theatre, though his family’s provincial circle was artistically voracious; he went to Moscow to study law, but abruptly quit to enrol in Vladimir Nemirovich-Danchenko’s drama class at the Moscow Philharmonic Society, where he shone for his versatility which encouraged Danchenko to enlist him into the new company he had formed with Konstantin Stanislavsky, which before long would be known as the Moscow Art Theatre. There he played Konstantin in the company’s ground-breaking revival of Chekhov’s The Seagull and later Tusenbach in the première of The Three Sisters. But life in a company, waiting for good parts, which were increasingly unforthcoming, was never going to satisfy his rangy energy, to say nothing of his increasing exasperation with what he took to be Stanislavsky’s slavish adherence to theatrical naturalism.
With a couple of fellow former company members, he quit the company and in 1902 staged a season in the Ukrainian town of Kherson. At first, he says, he followed Stanislavsky’s example, but from the second season – dubbed The Fellowship of the New Drama – and over two more seasons, in which the repertory increasingly favoured the Symbolist playwrights of whom the Belgian Maurice Maeterlinck was the most prominent, a theatre of atmospheres and subliminal emotions demanding, Meyerhold began to throw off the influence of Stanislavsky. This work culminated in a production of Przybyszewski’s Snow, “a symphony,” according to the Kherson company’s literary manger, “of snow and winter, of pacification and irrepressible longing.” This same year, 1904, Stanislavsky, faced with the failure of his production of three Maeterlinck plays at the Moscow Art Theatre, had a epiphany: “Is it possible,” he felt, “that we, artists of the stage, are doomed by the materiality of our bodies to eternal servitude and the representation of crude reality?” He determined to open a Theatre-Studio, and concluded that Meyerhold was the person to run it. It failed without ever producing anything, partly due to external circumstances – among them the 1905 uprising, which caused all theatres to be closed – but largely because the actors of the Moscow Art Theatre were unwilling to accept Meyerhold’s increasingly radical ideas, stimulated by his reading of the German director and theorist Georg Fuchs, whose The Theatre of the Future crystallized his thinking about the relationship of the actor to the text and the overall responsibility of the director for the final result. Fuchs’s later Revolution in the Theatre (1909) sowed even more fertile seeds which would grow into central aspects of Meyerhold’s vison of the theatre: on the one hand a rediscovery of ancient traditions of street theatre, popular festivals and Dionysian dithyrambs, on the other the development of incorporating modern and tasteful aesthetic elements; on the other hand, bringing stage and audience closer together.
From early in his career, Meyerhold, a feisty polemicist, sought to define his evolving aesthetic in witty and pugnacious occasional articles; some of his extremely colourful speeches were transcribed and preserved. His target was, increasingly, the Moscow Art Theatre, bogged down, as he saw it, by a limited notion of reality, an approach derived, he suggested, from the manically detailed work of the by then defunct theatre company of the Duke of Saxe-Meiningen, under their director Ludwig Cronegk; MAT’s work, he said, suffered from Cronegkitis (or sometimes Meinigenitis). He vigorously attacked the notion of realism as promulgated by Stanislavsky: “the actor is expected to rather than develop a sense of aestheticism which might balk at the representation of externally ugly, misshapen phenomena lose his self-consciousness…in the theatre, the spectator’s imagination is able to supply that which is left unsaid. It is this mystery and the desire to solve it which draw so many people to the theatre.” He quotes his friend Leonid Andreev: “the spectator should not forget for moment that an actor is performing before him, and the actor should never forget that he is performing before an audience with a stage beneath his feet and a set around him. Frequently, the more obvious the artifice, the more powerful the impression of life.”
After briefly resuming his work with the Fellowship of the New Drama, where he started to experiment with the use of Japanese movement, extending the forestage and abandoning painted backcloths, he was invited to join the prestigious St Petersburg Company of the distinguished actress-manager Vera Komissarzhevskya as both actor and director. After returning to Maeterlinck, he broke into entirely new territory with Aleksandr Blok’s Fairground Booth, where he engaged for the first time with commedia dell’arte and area lighting, flooding the stage with undifferentiated light. The following season his production of Pelléas and Mélisande was deemed a catastrophe, and he was in due course dismissed, but not before he finally directed a production – of Sologub’s Death’s Victory, in which he succeeded in breaking the fourth wall, transforming the relationship between public and players – which drew widespread critical acclaim.
Unexpectedly, Meyerhold’s dismissal from the Kommisarzhevsky company was followed immediately afterwards by his appointment as stage director (and occasional actor) at the Alexandrinsky Theatre and stage director the Imperial Marinsky Opera, an astonishing act of confidence on the part of the Director of Imperial Theatres, Vladimir Telyakovsky, who remarked in an interview that “Meyerhold, with his propensity for stirring people up, will be very useful in the state theatres. As regards his excesses, I am confident that he will curb them with us.” Meyerhold was not such an idealist that he failed to be aware of the opportunity offered him, and directed a number of extraordinary productions, both on the lyric and the dramatic stages, all but one designed by Diaghilev’s designer, Alexander Golovin, Tristan und Isolde and Gluck’s Orfeo deemed to be revelatory. In Schnitzler’s Pierrette’s Veil he further investigated his fascination with commedia dell’arte, as he did with Molière’s Dom Juan, creating huge dynamic energy on the stage. The absolute triumph of his period at the Alexandrinsky was a staggeringly epic production of Lermontov’s dark, fantastical Masquerade, with a cast of over 200, “the richest spectacle,” according to Meyerhold’s biographer, Edward Braun, “the Russian theatre had ever seen.” It was still being revived in 1941.
Astonishingly, during this inordinately demanding period, he threw himself (under the droll nom de guerre of Doctor Dapertutto) into directing at a small Petersburg venue called The Interlude. It was here that he directed Pierrette’s Veil (renamed Columbine’s Scarf), probing its potential darkness, in the manner of E T A Hoffman, and a new comedy, The Transfigured Prince, similarly swarming with dark energies. These small-scale but wildly inventive productions were, Meyerhold later said, crucial to his later development. He resumed teaching, occasionally directing his students in public performances; and collected his various articles and speeches into a volume called The Theatre. He also revived The Fairground Booth with new décor; at the interval a troupe of itinerant Chinese musicians performed.
Meyerhold’s theatrical instinct had nothing in it of the picturesque, the winsome. He conceived a fierce passion for popular theatre as the most vital of all forms. In his electrifying piece The Fairground Booth, he writes admiringly of the performer he calls the cabotin – more usually in French a word denoting ham actor but for Meyerhold an absolutely central figure.
Is a theatre without cabotinage possible? The cabotin is a kinsman to the mime, to the histrion, and the juggler; the cabotin can work miracles with his physical mastery; the cabotin keeps alive the true tradition of the true art of acting. It was with his help that the Western theatre came to full flower in the theatres of Spain and Italy in the seventeenth century…the mystery players themselves sought the help of the cabotins.
Would-be dramatists, say Meyerhold, should be made to write a few pantomimes.
He will be permitted to put words into the mouths of his characters, but first he must produce a scenario of movement. How long will it be before they inscribe in the theatrical tables the following law: words in the theatre are only embellishments on the design of movement?... in order to revive the theatre of the past, contemporary directors are finding it necessary to begin with pantomime, because when these silent plays are staged they reveal to directors and actors the power of the primordial elements of the theatre: the power of the mask, gesture, movement and plot.
In a paragraph which could just as easily have been penned by Craig, Meyerhold writes:
In the contemporary theatre, the actor has been replaced by ‘the educated reader’. ‘The play will be read in costume and make-up’ might as well be the announcement on playbills today. The new actor manages without the mask and the technique of the juggler. He has lost sight of the great masters of the art of acting. The actor has no need of the juggler’s art, no longer ‘plays’ but simply ‘lives’ on the stage. ‘Play-acting’, that magic word of the theatre, means nothing to him, because as an imitator he is incapable of rising to the level of improvisation which defends on infinite combinations and variations on all the ticks at the actor’s command…those who are delving into long-forgotten theories of dramatic art, are forcing actors to believe in the power and the importance of the art of acting.
It's noteworthy that Meyerhold, in the vanguard of theatrical modernity, is impelled, like Craig, to urge a return to the past in order to revitalise the theatre. This is not Modernism; if anything it is Fundamentalism, a return to first principles. In a similar vein, Meyerhold, noting the crucial importance of contrast:
The grotesque has its own attitude to the outward appearance of life. The grotesque deepens life’s outward appearance to the point where it ceases appear merely natural. Beneath what we see of life there are vast unfathomed depths. In its search foe the supernatural, the grotesque synthesises opposites, creates a picture of the incredible, and invites the spectator to solve the riddle of the inscrutable.
Meyerhold was now 40, tireless and dazzlingly inventive, infinitely interested in the possibilities of remaking theatre, as director, writer, teacher, company leader. The programme for his school amounts to a total reclamation of the theatrical past while not ignoring the innovators of the present day – Yevreinov, Komissarzhevsky, Jaques-Dalcroze, himself and Craig were all on the syllabus). In contrast to all this dynamic action, at the same age, Craig – just two years older than Meyerhold – had assumed the role of theatrical Savonarola, denouncing the work of almost every current practitioner, while continuing to pen visionary pieces outlining potential productions of his own, none of which he showed the slightest interest in actually realising. The school he had established in Florence in the Arena Goldoni was forcibly closed by the authorities; he spent most of the First World War drifting about Europe, as if everything was perfectly normal, notwithstanding the occasional inconvenience.
Meyerhold’s life and work, meanwhile, were about to change unimaginably, as was his country. Almost immediately after the October Revolution, he and just four other leading artists accepted an invitation from Anatoly Lunacharsky, the new People’s Commissar for Education, to discuss the reorganisation of the arts. He immediately saw it as not simply an opportunity to put his ideas into practice, and otherwise revitalise theatre, but as a means of resetting society at large. He joined the Bolshevik party in 1918; a year later, after having fallen into the hands of the White Guard, imprisoned and nearly executed, he was rescued by the Red Army, summoned to Moscow and appointed Head of the Theatrical Department for the Soviet Republic, at that extraordinary moment. Michael Glenny describes what was a golden period for Soviet Theatre:
In physical capacity alone its growth after 1917 was astonishing. In that year, Moscow had 16 theatres; in 1934 it had sixty…at the end of Tsarist rule, Russia could count a total of 250 theatres; twenty years later, the Soviet Union had 560 permanent theatres to say nothing of countless amateur and semi-professional theatres run by the armed forces, trade unions, collective farms etc.
All the norms of theatre were upended.
Theatres played a peculiarly important role in those days before radio broadcasting, as being virtually the only media for addressing and influencing large numbers of people simultaneously. The revolution also moved out of doors to deliver the revolutionary message to vast crowds who had never seen any kind of dramatic performance. The methods used were inevitably crude, but they were highly effective both as political propaganda, and as a means of democratizing the theatre and of awakening a taste for drama and spectacle among the masses…this explosion of activity began with the revolution, itself an intensely dramatic not to say theatrical series of events played out virtually on one stage – Petrograd – in the blinding limelight of the world’s attention.
In 1920, Nicolai Yevreinov, a former associate of the Komissarzhevsys, directed a restaging of the storming of the the Winter Palace with a cast of 8,000, exactly where the original storming of he palace had taken place. An audience of 100,000 sang the Internationale as a huge red flag was raised. Meyerhold directed Mayakovsy’s massive Mystery-Bouffe, which was not entirely successful. It had proved difficult to cast since the theatrical profession was suspicious of the Bolshevik’s. No such doubts for Meyerhold: he unreservedly gave himself over to the new order and his position within it, as precisely observed by a lynx-eyed actor in the company :
He was wearing a soldier’s greatcoat. And on his cap there was a badge with Lenin’s picture…in spite of its apparent simplicity, his appearance was somewhat theatrical, because although he was dressed modestly and without any superfluous ‘Bolshevik’ attributes, the style was still à la Bolshevik: the carelessly thrown-on greatcoat, the boots and puttees, the cap, the dark red woollen scarf – it was all quite unpretentious, but at the same time effective enough.
He harried the Moscow theatres into greater commitment to the revolution. He himself revived The Dream in a production of great Futurist severity; even Nadezhda Krupskaya, Lenin’s wife, found the adaptation crude. A more serious anxiety was that the austerity and angularity of the design might not appeal to the party’s working-class supporters. This anxiety seems to have been misconceived; the play ran for over a hundred performances. Meanwhile, Meyerhold took on the daunting task of trying to establish the principles on which a theatre serving a post-revolutionary audience should be organised. He rejected the idea that any actor – any theatre worker – could be considered apolitical, insisting that the only theatre which could become exemplary in “this mighty revolutionary age” was a revolutionary theatre. Noting “the craze for theatricalization which has gripped almost the entire territory of the Russian Soviet Republic” and the fact that there are reports of villages with 5 theatres, he vows to have as little as possible to do with the professional theatre, “partly for autobiographical reasons.” He returned to Mystery-Bouffe, taking his scenic innovations much further, breaking down the barriers between audience and actors, incorporating circus performers and acrobatic tricks, using a huge ramp up which the actors slithered and crawled. The production ran triumphantly for 5 months, playing over that time to an audience of some 120,000.
Meanwhile, the Civil war, Soviets versus the aristocratic Whites, had taken its toll; at this point, in 1921, the revolution had to confront financial reality, inaugurating the New Economic Plan, which caused a temporary return to capitalism, and the abrupt closure of what he had called “the theatre of those 5 magical letters – The First Theatre of the R.S.F.S.R. (Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic). Before this blow, he had outlined the way in which the company would operate: joint work with the actors on adapting the plays, using improvisation; changes in what he calls “the psychological make-up of the actors”. This means “no pauses, no psychology, no ‘authentic emotions’…plenty of light, plenty of high spirits, plenty of grandeur, plenty of infectious enthusiasm, unlaboured creativity, the participation of the audience in the corporate creative act of the performance.” He insists that his goal is “the unification of the stage with the auditorium.” Elsewhere he says: “Whereas before we treated a literary work with a certain degree of care and consideration, today we are no longer such fetishists, we do not fall on our knees and cry reverently “Shakespeare! Verhaeren!” Now we have to protect then interests not of the author but of the spectator.” Finally, he comes out unequivocally on the side of Modernist Art, with guns blazing:
For us, ‘decorative’ settings have no meaning; decoration is for the Secessionists and restaurants in Vienna and Munich; spare is ‘The World of Art’, ‘Rococo’ and the painstaking detail of museum exhibits…we have only to talk to the latest followers of Picasso and Tatlin to know at once that we are dealing with kindred spirits…we are building just as they are building… For us the art of manufacturing is more important than any tediously pretty patterns and colours. What do we want with pleasing pictorial effects? What the modern spectator wants is the placard, the juxtaposition of the surfaces and shapes of tangible materials! To sum up, both we and they want to escape from the box of the theatre onto the wide-open stage – and our artists will be delighted throw away their brushed and take up axes, picks and hammers to hack stage sets out of the materials of raw nature.
This heroic, uncompromisingly radical statement (co-written with his assistant Valery Bebutov) sows the seeds of what in time would be Meyerhold’s undoing. His absolute belief in the revolution and the fundamental change it had at a stroke wrought in the attitudes of the People, both to society and to art, had more than a touch of wishful thinking about it. His unremitting denunciation of the Moscow Art Theatre in his remaining years, as well as his passionate embrace of the avant-garde, would prove to be his undoing. Neither the people nor their rulers shared his radicalism. The statement shows how quickly he had moved in a mere decade from a belief, as he put in an interview in 1913, that “the stage is a world of marvels and enchantment, it is breathless joy and strange magic.” His new thinking was long gestated, from at the least 1901, in his comment in a letter to Chekhov:
I am irritated by those comrades of mine who have no desire to rise above the narrow interests of their caste and respond to the interests of society. Yes, the theatre is capable of playing an enormous part in the transformation of the whole of existence!
Something obviously continued to gnaw at him about his unrelenting attacks on the Moscow Art Theatre, particularly insofar as it concerned Stanislavsky, for whom he harboured an ever-greater respect. His view of the older man resembles Craig’s devotion to Irving. For Meyerhold, writing in 1921, Stanislavsky was a prisoner within the Moscow Art Theatre.
With a tirelessly supple body, a voice of enormous range, a face with amazing mimetic properties, (without resort to make-up), eyes described by Lensky as the most riveting in the theatre, a love of rich and stately costumes, a predilection for Shakespeare, Molière, Pushkin, Schiller – this man, born for the theatre of extravagant grotesque and enthralling tragedy, was forced, year after year, by the pressures of a philistinism inimical to him to break and distort his gallic temperament in catering to the tastes of the patrons of fashionable restaurants, the proprietors of shops on the Kuznetsky Most, and the owners of banking-houses and coffee shops.
It is a mark of the breadth of Meyerhold’s sympathies that he sought to incorporate this man whom he so admired into his world-view, though in fact it was Stanislavsky who initiated the famous naturalistic Method that Meyerhold so despised, and was, to Chekhov’s great frustration, a fervent proponent of scenic realism. It is astonishing that the Meyerhold of 1921, seeking to smash bourgeois theatre and drag the Russian playhouse into the 20th century, was moved to write an extravagant hommage to the last great survivor of the theatrical régime.
That autumn, he was back in harness, as Director of the State Higher Theatre, in which capacity he instituted the programme of physical training which he dubbed Bio-Mechanics, which ensured the physicality of performances. The first production was a direct collaboration with the Constructivists, under the supervision of Lyubov Popova, who joined the school’s staff, and created a dazzling mechanical landscape which presented many opportunities for Bio-Mechanical activity. The play was The Magnanimous Cuckold by the contemporary Belgian dramatist Crommelynck, the production antic, lewd, and physically exuberant and demonstrated that for all his avant-gardisme, Meyerhold had lost none of his joy in the theatre, nor his sense of its roots. He was not in the business of punishing audiences. He wanted them witty, active, engaged. The school’s next offering was Sukhovo-Kobylin’s Tarelkin’s Death, a savage satire on the Tsarist police. Meyerhold conceived the production, with middling success, in the style of the contemporary Eccentrist movement; thereafter, he staged Earth Rampant in the grotesque style, but with due dignity for the scenes in which the fallen of the revolution were nobly honoured. It was revived in 1924 for the 5th Congress of the Comintern to an audience of 2,500, which marked another endorsement of Meyerhold, who had recently been honoured as a People’s Artist of the republic. His radical new version of Ostrovsky’s masterpiece, The Forest, in which, significantly, the two principal figures are actors, took the play by the scruff of its neck and radically reconceived its characters, social relationships and tone. It was an enormous success, with 1,700 performances over the years.
Give Us Europe!, an adaptation of an adaptation, was further adapted by Meyerhold. To the author’s protests, he replied: “In my theatre, which serves and will continue to serve the cause of the revolution, we need tendentious plays, plays with only one aim: to serve the Revolution.” He saw the cast as actor-tribunes, not conduits for character, insisting that they work from the outside in. The actor’s absolute mastery of his own body is the only way forward. Here Meyerhold oddly chimes with Craig, specifically in his description of Irving’s method, his iron control over his own emotions and physical expression: the mind, not the heart, is the source of all acting. “If we place him in an environment in which gymnastics and all forms of sport are both available and compulsory, we shall achieve the new man who is capable of any form of labour. Only via the sports arena can we approach the theatrical arena.” Again, Meyerhold, as different from each other, personally and politically, as two human beings could be, arrive at the same conclusion. “There are many people who believe that Art is different from Sport,” he says in A Living Theatre (1913), “whereas all art is a form of sport. A racer and an artist are brothers. And it is because people have thought that art is possessed of a different spirit from that of true sport, that it has come to be held a commonplace, commercial thing – a thing which all the younger generation are despising. You must play at Art as you play at cricket.”
Of course in Meyerhold’s case, there was an agenda. “When the actor-tribune lifts the mask of the character to reveal his true nature to the spectator he does not merely speak the lines furnished by the dramatist, he uncovers the roots from which the lines have sprung…the actor-tribune needs to re-examine his technique and give back to the theatre what it lost during the period of reaction when it slid into the quagmire of apolitical chit-chat.” The Government Inspector (1926) was not the end but the culmination of Meyerhold’s anti-apolitical chit-chat enterprise, a monumental ambition, since it involved taking on a play everyone in the audience thought they knew and making it entirely, fiercely, painfully pertinent to the life of the newly liberated nation.
Michael Chekhov, himself a great Khlestakov under Stanislavsky’s direction, wrote of the production that “in Meyerhold’s hands, The Government Inspector started to grow and swell until it split wide open; through the cracks there gushed a raging torrent; Dead Souls, The Nevsky Prospect, Podkolyosin, Poprishev, the dreams of the mayoress, horrors, guffaws, raptures, the screams of ladies, the fears of petty bureaucrats…” This highly wrought production – the most written-about production in the history of the theatre, says Edward Braun, Meyerhold’s biographer – was deeply controversial, largely due to the incorporation into the text of passages from many other works of Gogol, but strongly attended, as was Meyerhold’s production of The Bed Bug, by his closest friend Mayakovsky. Shostakovich wrote the music, cheeky and obsessive, for which he was soundly chastised by the authorities, who were generally dismayed by the whole event, uncertain as to where exactly the satire was aimed. From here in on, Meyerhold’s relationship with authority started to get complex. Mayakovsky’s next play, The Bath House, a savage satire of bureaucracy. Neither they nor the public much cared for it, and it had to be cancelled, to Meyerhold’s rage. Mayakovsky, devastated, killed himself, a bitter blow to Meyerhold, who counted him as his closest friend. Meyerhold had long agitated for the right to tour the company’s work. After much negotiation, he was allowed to visit Germany and Paris, where they had a triumph from an audience that included louis Jouvet, Picasso, Dullin, Cocteau, Derain and Baty, all of whom sprang to their feet at the end of the show.
Back in Russia, Meyerhold continued working in a darkening atmosphere. His feminist production of The Lady of the Camelias, focussing on the transactional treatment of women as commodities, and starring his wife Zinaida, was given the cold shoulder by an increasingly hostile press. He returned to directing opera, Tchaikovsky’s Queen of Spades, rewriting the libretto to take it closer to Pushkin. The press were curmudgeonly, their default mode now with Meyerhold, though many people – including Shostakovich – thought it full of illuminating conceptions. In his own theatre, he attempted to pay hommage to Chekhov to celebrate the 75th anniversary of his birth. It failed, over-conceived. Meyerhold was a ready target for Zhdanov and his campaign against formalism, and he opened himself to attack by making a fearless speech with the witty title of Meyerhold against Meyerholditis. From the reaction of his auditors, it is clear that he was a marked man. In December 1937, a close associate of Stalin’s went to a production at the Meyerhold Theatre, and walked out in disgust. The theatre was closed, by order of the Politburo, on 7 January 1938, on the grounds that ‘throughout its entire existence, the Meyerhold Theatre has been unable to free itself from thoroughly bourgeois Formalist positions.’ His works were duly proclaimed antagonistic and alien to the Soviet people. Astonishingly, the ailing Stanislavsky, now installed at the Stanislavsky Opera, then invited Meyerhold to be his assistant. He gratefully accepted; shortly after Stanislavski’s death, following the older man’s precise instructions (“Take care of Meyerhold; he is my sole heir in the theatre – here or anywhere else”) he was appointed director of the company, where he continued working until he was instructed to choreograph a spectacle in Leningrad involving 30,000 athletes. He returned to Moscow, in June of 1939, to address a palpably hostile conference of theatre directors, giving a spirited and lucid account of himself, sharply criticising some of his colleagues.
The end is terrible. On returning to Leningrad, he was arrested. Then his wife (who two years before had written to Stalin to complain that Meyerhold was the victim of a conspiracy by and former members of the disbanded ) was brutally murdered in their flat. He was then taken to NKVD headquarters in Moscow, where he was handed over to the notorious torturer . He broke down, confessing to being a spy for Britain and Japan.
In his last days, he wrote a letter to Molotov, the Soviet Prime Minister of the Soviet government, which was retained in police files, where it was discovered after the dissolution of the USSR. In it he wrote:
I was made to lie face down and beaten on the soles of my feet and my spine with a rubber strap. They sat me on a chair and from above, with considerable force... For the next few days, when those parts of my legs were covered with extensive internal haemorrhaging, they again beat the red-blue-and-yellow bruises with the strap and the pain was so intense that it felt as if boiling water was being poured on these sensitive areas. I howled and wept from the pain. They beat my back with the same rubber strap and punched my face, swinging their fists from a great height ... The intolerable physical and emotional pain caused my eyes to weep unending streams of tears. Lying face down on the floor, I discovered that I could wriggle, twist and squeal like a dog when its master whips it ... When I lay down on the cot and fell asleep, after 18 hours of interrogation, in order to go back in an hour's time for more, I was woken up by my own groaning and because I was jerking about like a patient in the last stages of typhoid fever ... “death, oh most certainly, death is easier than this!” the interrogated person says to himself. I began to incriminate myself in the hope that this, at least, would lead quickly to the scaffold.
He was sentenced to death by firing squad on 1st February, 1940, and executed the next day.
His speech to the Directors’ Conference had ended with a remarkable peroration, an artist’s testament:
In a true work of art, form and content are inseparable; that is what is so tantalising for the creative artist! The artist experiences pure joy in the creative process when he steeps himself in the content of a work and finally finds the appropriate form for it. Once he is convinced of the rightness of the form, he feels it pulsating with the true life of the content.