Garrick
Review of Garrick by Ian McIntyre
Every age redefines acting, almost without exception in terms of greater realism. The New Actor, fresh on the scene, startles by his immediacy and truthfulness, making other actors seem stagey, hammy, corny. In time, the new truthfulness becomes widely current, and is in turn revealed as stagey, hammy, corny, to be replaced by the New Actor; a familiar process across the whole range of human activity.
It occurred with particular abruptness in the case of David Garrick, whose sudden eruption into London’s theatrical life in 1742 with his sensational portrayal of Richard III shocked the city and the profession.
The almost unknown 25-year-old wine merchant from Lichfield gave an account of the role of such vividness and confidence that older actors of the day were immediately thrown on to the defensive. “If this young fellow is right,” said James Quin, one of the reigning stars of the time, “then we have all been wrong.”
What was it that so electrified Garrick’s contemporaries? In a word, actuality. The actors of the mid-18th century were still recycling the rhetorical French style which they had adopted with the reopening of the theatres at the Restoration: the manner was declamatory, impressive, ponderous; Quin himself – the mighty Quin, a great barrel of a man with a deeply sonorous voice and the swaying motion of an ocean-going vessel – was the supreme exemplar of this style. The impact of Garrick, slight (only 5’3”), nimble, swift in thought and flexible in utterance, responsive to every impulse in the language and development in the character, was clearly breathtaking.
Audiences felt that they were for the first time in the presence of the character himself, rather than a stylised representation of him, because they were able to see his thinking, minute by minute; moreover, the quite exceptional expressiveness of Garrick’s somewhat bland features, which seemed possessed by the whole gamut of emotions in rapid succession, was a marvel in itself, a sort of magic trick that defied disbelief. His senior contemporaries preferred on the whole to demonstrate the conventionalised lineaments of a role; they were reproducing the past. Garrick was thrillingly, hair-raisingly present.
His career took off instantly and with bewildering variety; his range encompassed high comedy, farce and tragedy – often on the same evening. When he played King Lear for the first time (at the ripe age of 26) he followed it on the same bill with Cibber’s after-piece The Schoolboy, in which he played the 15-year-old Master Johnny. Needless to say, his fellow players didn’t take his ascendancy lying down. “This might be a proper representation of a mad tailor,” sniffed the comedian Samuel Foote, “but by no means corresponds with my idea of King Lear.”
The criticisms of his contemporaries bear a striking similarity to those offered to one of this century’s thespian mould-breakers, Laurence Olivier, whose early performances in Shakespeare were held to be a smack in the face for the values of nobility, lyricism, elevated tone and resonance. In fact, Olivier and Garrick have a number of things in common; how Garrick would have enjoyed Olivier’s famous doubles of Oedipus and Mr Puff, Hotspur and Justice Shallow. Like Olivier, Garrick was criticised for his naturalistic phrasing; his pauses were analysed in minute detail.
It was an age when theatre was the great metropolitan sport: the rival companies at Covent Garden and Drury Lane had their supporters and their detractors, whose conduct make the most extreme football hooligans seem like pussycats. The best job to have in London c1750 was a theatre repairer: at the slightest provocation the pit would smash the benches, tear down the lighting sconces, and set fire to the curtains. The workmen would move in, swiftly reconstruct the auditorium, and the next day or the day after it would be business as usual, until the next offence from the stage, which could be almost anything: inaudibility, price increases, political incorrectness (betraying Francophilia, for example). Even Garrick, on whom the audience bestowed almost continuous favour, was hauled over the coals in this manner from time to time, thought there is no record of him being made to kneel to the audience in contrition, the fate of many of his fellow-players.
By 1747, a mere five years after his debut, Garrick was co-manager of Drury Lane, his reign inaugurated with a prologue written by his former schoolmaster and fellow Lichfielder, Samuel Johnson, with whom he had a somewhat uncomfortable life-long friendship. “Tis yours this night to bid the reign commence,” the prologue proclaimed, “Of rescued nature and reviving sense.” And he was true to his word. Over the next 20 years of his tenure, he raised standards, of acting, lighting, scenic design and of the general conditions of theatre-going. The 18th century playhouse was not the cesspit of the Restoration, but it was very noisy and the division between backstage and front of house not always clear. Garrick helped reform all this. As far as his encouragement of new writing is concerned, his record is mixed, but it is greatly to his credit that he brought back into circulation a number of Shakespeare’s plays, in more or less mutilated versions, but none the less always done with a great vivacity and imagination.
It was inevitable that he should have been the front man for the Shakespeare jubilee of 1769; the beginnings of the Shakespeare industry can readily be discerned in this event, which passed uncomfortably from pageant to pomposity until it was rained off. It confirmed Garrick’s position not only at the head of his profession but, long before Henry Irving’s symbolic knighthood supposedly made acting respectable, as a distinguished member of society; his acquaintance included dukes and marquesses, and indeed the intelligentsia of Britain and Europe.
His acting was immensely influential on both sides of the Channel, not simply in theatrical terms, but philosophically. As part of the great rationalist inquiry into the human condition, the Enyclopédistes, and particularly Diderot, were fascinated by his ability apparently to create emotions at will: what did this tell us about the human brain? The Paradox of Acting, Diderot’s famous dialogue, identifies what has become the central issue of acting: to feel or not to feel? “Garrick will put his head between two folding doors and in the course of five or six seconds his expression will change successively from wild delight to temperate pleasure, from this to tranquillity, from tranquillity to surprise, from surprise to blank astonishment, from that to sorrow, from sorrow to the air of one overwhelmed, from that to fright, from fright to horror, from horror to despair, and thence he will go up again to the point from which he started. Can his soul have experienced all these feelings, and played this kind of scale in concert with his face? I don’t believe it; nor do you.”
If this was face-pulling, it is on a titanic scale. Johnson crushingly observed: “David looks much older than he is . . . such an eternal restless fatiguing play of the muscles must certainly wear out a man’s face before its real time.”
To the day of his retirement, audiences were astonished by his performances. He had few failures –Othello, Romeo, Hotspur – and seemed to understand his own range. He had a repertory of more than 90 roles; small wonder that, exhausted by management, acting, directing and writing – innumerable prologues and after-pieces and a number of very enjoyable full-length plays – he took a long sabbatical; he was 46, had acted for 21 years, and seriously wondered whether he hadn’t lost the taste for it. After 18 months, he returned, renewed, and finally retired at the early age of 60. His health was by now poor, and death – from that savage kidney condition uraemia (“the stone”), which also claimed Mozart – came quite soon after. His obsequies were of the most splendid; the nation mourned.
Ian McIntyre’s book is immensely thorough, well-organised and lucidly written. It is by far the most complete account, and by far the longest, of this exemplary actor, of whom there have been surprisingly few biographies. He sketches in the political and social background with great clarity, and there are many delightful asides and brief character sketches of Garrick’s contemporaries. It is not exactly a Richard Holmesian biography, however; one does not quite feel that one has met the man. Nor is it a book of philosophical inquiry: Diderot’s meditation on the phenomenon of Garrick hardly merits a mention, nor is there any attempt to analyse his art or its sources. In mitigation, it may be said that Garrick was in many ways a rather unremarkable man, hard-working, happily married, lacking the existential drive of a Kean, or even the recklessness and savagery of his own contemporary, Macklin. And his life was essentially a success story: he became famous early and was admired to the day of his death, and beyond.
In a sense that makes a rather dull story. However, McIntyre’s Garrick will surely be the standard life for many years, until somebody attempts a slightly more deconstructed version of what is one of the most striking phenomena in the history of acting.