Grace Pervades
Theatre Royal Bath programme
When on his farewell tour in 1905, Henry Irving appeared for his curtain call in Swansea, someone in the audience started softly singing Lead Kindly Light, the whole audience joined in. Not long afterwards on the same tour, after playing the title role in Becket in Bradford, he suddenly died. The last lines he uttered on stage had been “Into thy hands, O Lord, into thy hands.” When his lifeless body was borne through the streets at the beginning of his final journey back to London, thousands of people assembled on the pavements in perfect silence, a response repeated tenfold when he was interred amidst high pomp in Westminster Abbey. Cabmen going about their work that day wore black bows on their whips.
All this for an actor? A mere actor? The intense national mourning for Irving was the culmination of everything he had striven for in his life: the distancing of the actor and the theatre itself from bawdy disrepute and intellectual dismissal, occupying instead a central place in the national landscape. His knighthood, bestowed in 1895, the first awarded to an actor, was powerfully symbolic of the respectability the theatre had acquired in the forty years since he had started acting professionally. That he was personally responsible for this transformation was not in doubt. “The actor’s world he lifted up,” said one of the many poems inspired by his demise, “From base report and evil sway/Into the purer light of day/Where art and beauty rule the play.”
This pre-eminence had not been easily won by the Somerset-born, Cornish-bred John Henry Brodribb, who took himself to London at the age of ten, starting his working life three years later as a clerk. At the age of 18, he had committed himself to the theatre, under the confected name by which he would eventually become the uncontested leader of his profession. He spent ten dogged years in provincial theatres, learning his craft; despite lacking conventional good looks, being physically slender to the point of etiolation and vocally unreliable, he finally found his way to the metropolis, where at the age of 33, he met a key figure in his life: “Colonel” Hezekiah Linthicum Bateman, who having taken the Lyceum Theatre to promote his actress daughter, invited Irving to be her leading man. Bateman, who occupied roughly the same position in Irving’s life as “Colonel” Tom Parker in Elvis Presley’s, not only gave him a splendid London showcase, he initiated him into the dark arts of promotion. The pupil soon became a master.
The first two productions of Bateman’s tenure failed, at which point Irving urged on him a new version of a creaking old melodrama, The Polish Jew. Under the title The Bells, it was a prodigious success, above all for Irving, who at a stroke strode to the forefront of his profession with his chilling realisation of the murderous and guilt-haunted burgomaster. “When the final curtain fell,” said the Gazette, reviewing the sparsely attended first night, “the audience, after a gasp or two, realised that they had witnessed the most masterly form of tragic acting that the British stage had seen for many a long day, and there was a storm of cheers.” The hitherto obscure character actor took his curtain call like a star, “still pale, still haggard, still haunted, as it were, by the terror he had so perfectly counterfeited.”
The play, even in the Leopold Lewis version, is a feeble thing: Irving, by sheer creative will-power endowed it with disturbing intensity. This was his outstanding gift as an actor: the ability to engender atmospheres, to change the emotional temperature in the theatre. This is a very special kind of talent. It meant that most of his greatest successes were in plays of little literary merit, mere vehicles, creating in a sense very pure theatre, a theatre of effect, making theatrical bricks without straw, at the centre of which was his own often enigmatic, mysterious persona. Edward Gordon Craig, who had acted for him as a very young man, reported that as a tyro actor, Irving had become enraptured by the famous conjurers, the Davenport Brothers, importing one of their routines into the play he was doing with great success. Pondering this, says Craig, Irving embarked on a deep study of the works of Mesmer and Cagliostro, consciously developing his own mesmeric powers. For the rest of the century and beyond, into the brief Edwardian age, the actor held his audiences, if not always the critics, spellbound.
His pre-eminent position in the theatrical pantheon owed not a little to his conscious courting of the beau monde. He was a master of publicity, carefully establishing his position as the emblematic actor of the age. His backstage parties were legendary, including, on one notable occasion, Liszt, Gladstone, Whistler and Buffalo Bill; the editor of the Daily Telegraph usefully became an admirer, supporter and friend. Irving assiduously cultivated his monarchical connections, staging Royal Command performances at Windsor at his own expense, fostering a relationship with the Prince of Wales which benefited the whole profession, leading to the first awards of honours to actors, not least his own knighthood, which established him definitively, if proof were needed, as the leader of the profession.
At the Lyceum, he systematically raised standards of both playing and staging, employing small armies of stagehands, experimenting with light, hiring great painters and historically informed scene designers to create unexampled stage pictures. He particularly favoured historical subjects; driven by his ideals, mingling Evangelical Protestantism and medieval chivalry, he saw it as part of his mission to inform and elevate. His historical pageants were on a stupendous scale: when he staged Robespierre, he fielded an onstage cast of 65 actors and extras, with 350 staff out front and backstage. Plus a large orchestra.
Despite his regular engagement with the plays of Shakespeare, he had few successes with them; Shaw wickedly accused him of Bardicide. His Othello was a disaster (though later his Iago was considered definitive). If his Twelfth Night was an embarrassment, his much adapted Much Ado About Nothing restored the play to the repertory. The Merchant of Venice was an enduring success, his Shylock a complete reimagining of the character, far from the demonic figure current in the 19th century. Shaw’s principal beef against Irving was that he failed to engage with new playwriting. This was of no concern to his audiences, who, on both sides of the Atlantic, idolised him, despite critical responses to him that were frequently derogatory, even dismissive. Ad hominem attacks were the norm: William Archer airily dismissed him as “the actor-celebrity of the day”; Henry James went for the jugular: “Nature has done very little to make an actor of him. His face is not dramatic, it is the face of…anything other than a possible Hamlet or Othello. His figure is of the same cast, and his voice…is apparently wholly unavailable for the purposes of declamation.”
Irving’s masterstroke was to have engaged, for his first season as manager of the Lyceum, the services of Ellen Terry, an actor who was day to his night, summer to his winter, transparency to his complexity. A typical review from early in their association sums up her unique quality: “a performance of inimitable charm, full of movement, ease, and laughter…the most exquisite harmony and natural grace…” There were constant rumours (occasionally fuelled by Terry herself) about a possible amorous relationship between them. When, on his triumphant and life-changing first night as Matthias, his upper-crust wife Florence asked him, “are you going to go on making a fool of yourself all your life?” he famously left the carriage they were sharing, never to see her again. After that, he was never associated with any partner. Irving’s private life remains, like a great deal about this extraordinary and fathomlessly complex man, a mystery.
What, one may reasonably ask, is his legacy? Towards the end of his life, Irving unveiled a plaque to one of his great predecessors, James Quin. The stage journal The Era commented: “The present generation, with its keen sensitiveness, its intellectual activity, its moderation, its humanity, and its self-control, paid honour on Friday to the eighteenth century ideal of an actor: the three-bottle or six-bottle man, the rake, the duellist and the beau. How much humanity has advanced since those days of limited ablution and unlimited paint, powder and perfume; of foolish fighting and intemperate indulgence; of heartless repartee and scandalous epigram, it is hardly necessary to note.” From this distance, it is hard not to lament what has been lost: the great alternative carnival tradition, embracing the antipodes so alarming to the Victorians, celebrating the continuum of existence, exalting the communal body. Thanks to Irving, the theatre ceased to be part of us and became part of them. It has yet to be fully reclaimed.