Other Writing

← Back to Other Writing

I Joke Too Much

Introduction to Michael Rudman's I Joke Too Much

It’s a good job that Michael wrote this book, because otherwise the world would never know how funny he was. He certainly directed (superbly) a number of comedies, many of them smash hits – Frayn’s Clouds, Pinero’s The Magistrate, Neil Simon’s Brighton Beach, Merry Wives of Windsor, and, sublimely, Coward’s Fallen Angels, one of the funniest productions in my entire 65-year theatre-going history, Felicity Kendal and Frances de la Tour life-threateningly hilarious, and, a few years later, Present Laughter, in which I appeared, and whose only problem was how to control the tsunamis of laughter coming from the stalls. He was equally at home with the commanding heights of the repertory: Pirandello’s Six Characters In Search of an Author, a definitive Death of Salesman, Pinero’s dark and devastating The Second Mrs Tanqueray, and simply the best Godot I have ever seen. I missed his Long Day’s Journey Into Night, starring Robert Ryan, which he directed at the very dawn of his career, but those who did spoke of it with awe.

I loved and admired Michael in equal degree, though, like many of the best friendships, my relationship with him didn’t get off to the best start. I was a play reader at Hampstead during his tenure. An edict went out that all reports should henceforth be written on index cards. I bridled at this: my thoughts were far too profound to be contained on a mere card. I was huffing and puffing about this when Michael, whom I had never met, ambled into the foyer, lean and lanky, hair tousled, bronzed, glowing from an afternoon game of tennis (at least I assumed it was tennis) and I laid into him about cardgate. He listened for a little while and then he drawled: “You know something? We have too many readers at the moment. We won’t be needing your reports anymore.” “Fine,” I said, “that’s fine by me,” and stalked off, at which he said to my departing back, and this is the authentic Rudman touch, “Aren’t you going to re-write all your old reports on cards?” I seethed for a good year about this, and was therefore a little surprised when, not long after I arrived at the National Theatre (of which he was by then Deputy Director) to play Orlando and Mozart in Amadeus, he greeted me warmly and wittily, as if we were old friends. This was very good news, because he was a central figure at Peter Hall’s National Theatre. I quickly saw that, as well as directing a large number of extraordinarily diverse plays quite brilliantly and performing who knows what administrative tasks, he seemed to have a holding brief as a source of ironic good humour, a commodity of which one can never have enough, especially at that rather sobersides time at the National.

His timing was uncanny. Once, when Paul Scofield and I were rehearsing a tricky scene from Amadeus, an electrical connection above us started sputtering. We continued rehearsing (it was a tricky little scene) while flames started to engulf the ceiling. Eventually, black smoke was billowing through the room, as stage managers rushed everybody out. Finally, Paul and I came to the end of the scene and left the room, which was now a furnace. Exactly at that moment, Michael moseyed past – it’s the only word for it – and murmured “Simon Callow overacting again, I suppose”. I swear to God he was waiting for the right moment. He might even have started the fire just for the gag.

Every so often we would see each other at a gathering or in a restaurant and exchange views, and I always liked the cut of his jib. We weren’t by any means old chums, though on those occasions we behaved as if we were. We both left the National and our lives forked out in different directions. I saw his shows, he saw mine, and we liked what we saw – I in fact loved what I saw. Then, long ago, we found ourselves at the Savoy Hotel on Christmas Day with our respective significant others and Michael and Felicity insisted that we join their table for brandies and – well, more brandies, and once more I had this odd and very pleasing sensation of being old friends with him. We all staggered back to Carlyle Square, far too many more brandies were consumed, far too many stories were told, and my partner and I crawled away happy but barely compos mentis. I think this pattern was repeated over a couple of years, and then I started to cook Christmas dinner at home and that was the end of that.

And then, out of left field, to use a sporting metaphor which I don’t entirely understand (but Michael could have explained it to me) we were teamed by the Theatre Royal Bath to do Present Laughter together. Michael and Felicity and I had supper after they’d come to see the show I was in at the time and he was, as far I could gauge, genuinely delighted at the thought of directing me. And yet, you know: I was anxious. Not about his abilities nor about mine, but about how it would go between us in the rehearsal room. We all know from unhappy experience that some of the warmest social relationships can come to grief, so to speak, on the floor. He asked me to be present at all the auditions, which was a good way of getting the hang of each other’s approach; I always found myself agreeing with him, but still…

The moment we started rehearsals, I knew that everything was not just going to be all right: it was going to be wonderful. Without even noticing it at first, I sensed that something rather good was happening to my acting. Michael, always laconic, never didactic, was, by means of languid jokes and wicked anecdotes, adumbrating an approach to acting which was the perfect antidote to all my latent tendencies of bombast and energetic overkill. His blocking made it virtually impossible not to look at the person one was addressing, which was immediately a liberation. Everything suddenly had a very specific focus. He would say, drily, “I’m not against shouting. Shouting can be very effective. But choose your shouts.” Or, “Let’s see how quietly we can play this scene. Just out of interest”. No theory; no big stick. Everything done with a sprinkling of excellent and often self-deprecating anecdote. We both became deeply interested in the speed of thought at the heart of the play. One fine day he proposed that we should play a scene we were struggling with as quickly as humanly possible and the play instantly surrendered all of its laughs and all of its truth. The delight and approval of a man naturally given to ironic understatement were peculiarly gratifying. As we padded around the country with the show, the reviews everywhere said the same thing: “This play is much better than anyone gives it credit for.” I can’t think of more satisfying praise. It was entirely due to Michael. He trusted the play; he trusted us. Whenever he came to see the show on the tour, he would work it just a little further and our game would improve. I began to realise that his aim was a very simple one: to get the production – and the acting, which in an important sense, for him WAS the production – as good as possible. This is a surprisingly rare objective in the theatre. People have all sorts of agendas, but not often that one.

I by now knew that I had found that rare thing: a director with whom I had an almost perfect rapport. After his pastoral visits he and I would dine together and chew over the show and I realised more and more that under that raffish and languid exterior beat the heart of a true theatre romantic. This also is rare – too rare. Among directors there are visionaries, ten-a-penny; there are careerists, ditto (often the same people, oddly enough). But there are few who deeply and tenderly love the theatre and love actors. Our conversations often summoned up shades of actors and of productions gone, and Michael’s love and knowledge of them was comprehensive and profound. This was a strong enough bond, to be sure, but it turned out that our sympathy was based on something even greater than that. I shyly disclosed one day that I am an Honorary Citizen of Texas, a sublime honour bestowed on me in an absent-minded moment by the Mayor of Austin, Tex, when I was directing a movie from Carson McCuller’s Ballad of the Sad Café. It is as fellow Texans that we approached the work of Noël Coward, and as Texans that we approached our future work, which alas proved to be just one more play: François Billetdoux’s mordant masterpiece Chin-Chin, which contrary to the expectations of its title is no frothy comedy, but a dark and savage play about two people who drink each other to death. We toured it around the country, to sometimes baffled audiences, who had, I suspect, hoped for a bit of light-hearted frou-frou. Despite this, I’ve almost never enjoyed a play more. “I want this to be the best acting the West End has seen for decades,” said Michael. “Perhaps ever.” A simple thought, but a noble and an inspiring one. I’d serve any day under a Captain whose colours those are.

The West End, alas, never got to experience it. The producer, the late Bill Kenwright, who on principle never read the plays he put on, was appalled to discover that what he had thought was going to be a bit of fluff was in fact a savage anatomy of self-delusion, and thenceforward preferred to forget all about it.

It was my last professional experience with Michael. We met often for lunch and sometimes supper, which he always insisted on paying for. He was generosity itself, a great host. We talked most of all about his plays, the plays he had written, which I prized very highly, but about which he was uncharacteristically diffident. He was always interested in my life. In those days I had been single for a while. “Are you dating?” was always his first question. One day, I was able to say yes. “Who is it?” “Not in the business,” I said. “His name’s Sebastian Fox.” “That’s a good sign,” he said. “Someone whose name begins with S and ends with X.” He was quite right: reader, I married him.

I Joke Too Much, as well as being full of shafts of the Michael I loved and bitterly miss, is also an account of a rare director – one who, without theory, without political programme, without designs on the text, knew how to reach the core of a play and liberate the actors into inhabiting it with both depth and freshness. He was the perfect exemplar of what appears to be a dying art. He’s missed on every level and on all counts.

Simon Callow 15/03/2026

← Back to Other Writing

© Simon Callow 2013-26