My Name Is Orson Welles
“My Name Is Orson Welles”, exhibition catalogue, Cinémathèque française, 2025.
Orson Welles haunts the history of film in the 20th century. He was, on many levels, as actor, director, and writer, perhaps the best equipped film-maker of them all, but despite the extraordinary range and depth of the gifts he brought to the party, the final reckoning seems to fall oddly short, his output often held to be erratic, or disappointing. Yet he never ceased to fascinate. His work and the commentary on it – on him – are inseparable: the unrelenting inquisition into Welles, forever being held to account in the court of critical opinion for supposedly squandering his great gifts, is an essential part of his allure. Like the Ancient Mariner, Welles himself was irrepressibly impelled to come before the public to tell his story, over and over again, with many variations and a somewhat impressionistic attitude to the facts. He has a good claim to being the most interviewed, most documented film director of the twentieth century. This was not entirely to his advantage: his personal profile had become more prominent than his work. “They no longer review my films,” he complained, “they review me.”
From a very early age, he was a gift to journalists in search of sensational copy. His first newspaper profile appeared in Madison, Wisconsin when he was 10. Thereafter, as a very young travelling player, he was featured in papers in Dublin, Chicago and New Orleans. Once he arrived at the Negro Theatre Project to direct Macbeth in Harlem at the age of 20, the New York press fell on him hungrily, churning out rhapsodic Boy Wonder pieces, describing his admittedly remarkable childhood and youth in extravagantly romanticised terms, celebrating first his ground-breaking work in the theatre – the Voodoo Macbeth, the Black Magic Dr Faustus and the Fascist Caesar – then his radio experiments, culminating in the notorious War of the Worlds broadcast. For having perpetrated this, they acclaimed him (quite erroneously, as it happens) as a brilliant showman who had deliberately fooled the American public; his image adorned the front pages of newspapers around the world, and Hitler, Welles used to claim, cited the incident in the Reichstag as an example of the gullibility of the American public.
This image of Welles as an audacious provocateur drew the excited attention of Hollywood, with which, at the age of 24 – having never so much as even appeared in a film – he negotiated an unparalleled three-film contract with RKO Pictures as actor-director-producer, with the right to final cut, virtually unheard of for studio films. At first he was unable to come up with a viable project, which allowed resentful insiders to gloat publicly over his apparent failure; when he did finally deliver his first film, Citizen Kane, the press baron William Randolph Hearst, the supposed model for Kane, did everything in his considerable power to have it pulped, but a sustained campaign by the liberal press demanding its release finally prevailed, whereupon it was immediately and almost universally acclaimed as the greatest film ever made. The Boy Wonder was now enthroned as a towering triple-threat genius. He was just 26.
A mere 18 months later he was almost literally thrown out of RKO along with the garbage, his second film for the studio, The Magnificent Ambersons, having been butchered by the company during his absence in Brazil. He set out – only weeks after the US had joined the Allies against the Axis powers – to make a vast and quixotically ambitious epic, allegedly to support the war effort, called It’s All True, only a single (admittedly superb) sequence of which was ever completed at the time. RKO suspended his Brazilian budget and Welles returned to Hollywood with his tail between his legs. The Magnificent Ambersons, released in the studio’s truncated and sentimentalised version as part of a double bill, was dismissed by the critics as a damp squib, the triple-threat genius now redefined as a truant and a renegade. After his defenestration by RKO, Welles made two more Hollywood films, first The Stranger for Sam Spiegel, then The Lady from Shanghai, starring his recently divorced wife, Rita Hayworth, for Harry Cohn’s Columbia Pictures. The newspapers were agog at his having persuaded Hayworth to dye her famously red tresses blonde, but largely indifferent to the film. Neither that nor The Stranger (a rare box office success for him) did anything to rehabilitate him in Hollywood.
He had meanwhile flung himself back into the theatre (a colossal and financially disastrous production of a musical version of Around the World in Eighty Days), into radio broadcasting (comedy and political commentary) and increasingly radical journalism. All through this period, he was highly active politically until, in 1947, his artistic and political capital apparently exhausted, having shot but only partially edited an epic and stylised Macbeth, he withdrew to Europe. There he made a considerable living acting in somewhat overblown Hollywood epics, transformed into a dashing leading man in historical romances like Cagliostro and Prince of Foxes. But it was The Third Man, a film for which he had grudgingly spared a couple of weeks out of his busy schedule, which made him a bona fide film star. In it, he appeared for the first time on film without make-up, making him instantly recognisable.
Meanwhile, he started funding his own work as a director, beginning with a film of Shakespeare’s Othello, shot, by comparison with the Hollywood epics in which he had been acting, on a shoestring, filmed across two continents in fits and starts, a fact widely commented on in his native land. The image of Welles – comedian? political activist? film star? director? producer? maverick? – had become blurred beyond recognition, his constantly shifting profile almost impossible to identify. To confuse matters even more, in Britain he made his television debut in the startlingly original form of Orson Welles’ Sketch Book, a series of six engaging fifteen-minute programmes in which, addressing the audience directly with matchless charm, he spoke live on his chosen subject, impromptu and with perfectly judged eloquence, all the while skilfully drawing the incident or person in question. There followed, also on British television, a series called Around the World with Orson Welles, which took him to Paris and London and included two programmes on the Basque Country which remain to this day constantly and admiringly viewed in that part of Spain. The series was highly popular until, that is, he made an episode celebrating bullfighting, which proved to be a step too savage for the great British public.
All this was followed breathlessly by the press. The first (tiny) biography of Welles – more of a pamphlet, really, written by an awe-struck 19-year-old Englishman, Roy Alexander Fowler – had appeared in 1946, shortly after the European release of Kane, and consisted of a bewildered (and sometimes bewildering) summary of what he had achieved so far. Ten years later, The Fabulous Orson Welles, a much-circulated book by the British film journalist Peter Noble, appeared. Heavily indebted to Welles himself, it presented him as a superhuman, if unpredictable, master of the arts of acting and directing, both on stage and on film; its fanciful version of Welles’s personal life might better have been entitled The Fabulist Orson Welles. He worked extensively in Britain in both mediums, baffling critics with the apparent inconsistency of his output there, which included on the West End stage a ponderous Othello and then, a few years later, a brilliantly theatrical Moby-Dick with only rigging for décor. Despite its exhilarating impact, for some London theatregoers Welles’s version of Melville, framed as a play within a play, with Welles himself as the actor-manager playing the part of Ahab, seemed like an historical throwback by comparison with the avant-garde masterpiece Waiting for Godot, which only a couple of months later opened in a theatre just a few hundred yards away. There was for many people a curious feeling that this great innovator was somehow a reversion to an earlier era, that his persona was out of step with the times. To a degree that did his reputation no favours, the personal impact of this dashing, eloquent, giant of a man dominated the discourse surrounding his work. Welles’s friend the critic Kenneth Tynan succinctly encapsulated this impression when he described him in print as “a fair bravura actor, a good bravura director, but an incomparable bravura personality.”
In 1955, after attempting and failing to create a film on the basis of his stage Moby-Dick, Welles returned to the United States to act in and direct a King Lear in the New York theatre which was widely dismissed; having broken both of his ankles, he played the part in a wheelchair, which seemed to many people just another stunt. Almost immediately after the production closed he went to Las Vegas to perform conjuring tricks interspersed with Shakespeare monologues, both of which he did with some panache and to great critical acclaim, but also to the bafflement of serious Welles-watchers, those who still reposed faith in him as the white hope of the American film and theatre.
Time for a new medium: he had a highly stimulating encounter with American television for Desilu Productions, creating The Fountain of Youth, a still startlingly original short film, which exploited the medium in entirely new ways. It was critically acclaimed and even won a prize, but its impact on the ratings was negligible; Welles never again worked for American television as a director. After acting in an episode of I Love Lucy again for Desilu Productions, he acted in a Hollywood film, Man in the Shadow, and then finally returned to film directing, largely thanks to the influence of Charlton Heston, cast in the lead of a film in which Welles had been asked to play a corrupt detective. Heston suggested to the producers that Welles might also be hired to direct the film (Badge of Evil, as it was then known). The studio – Universal – reacted, said Heston, as if he had suggested that his grandmother should direct it. Finally, they were persuaded, Welles rewrote the script and plunged in, but after a brilliantly inventive and bold shoot, on time and under budget, he fell out with the studio during the editing process; unsupported by Universal, the film, with reshoots not directed by Welles, was, like The Magnificent Ambersons, perfunctorily released as part of a double bill, receiving little attention or appreciation. Welles’s reputation as a director on stage and film had reached a nadir.
Meanwhile, in June of 1958, across the Atlantic Ocean, an altogether more sophisticated appreciation of Welles and his work than the incurious accounts of Fowler or Noble appeared in the magazine Cahiers du Cinéma, the first of two probing interviews led by André Bazin, who, with Jean-Charles Tacchella, had first interviewed Welles in L’Écran Français as early as 1948. That same year Bazin wrote a short book about Welles, revising it just before his death in 1958. In it, he plays down the idea of Welles as a showman, treating him instead as a great artist, one of the greatest the medium had produced. Cahiers interviewed him several times subsequently and strongly influenced the continental perception of Welles as a fiercely intellectual innovator, his every frame studied in minute detail, each phrase uttered by even the most minor character subjected to forensic examination. In 1963, Welles’s friend and collaborator Maurice Bessy – ghost writer of the novel derived from Mr Arkadin and published under Welles’s name – wrote a book about him drawing on their personal acquaintance, eschewing the technical discussions which had characterised the two early Cahiers interviews. Instead, Bessy ventured into interesting but inevitably speculative psychological probings.
Welles himself reacted to all this with hilarity, but now to his surprise he found himself to be fast becoming a hero of cinéastes everywhere, even in his native land, where a new generation of radical and keenly analytical critics – Parker Tyler, Manny Farber and Andrew Sarris among them – was seriously (though not uncritically) appreciative of his work, Sarris solemnly anointing him a bona fide auteur. In 1961, there was a further significant development in the evolution of Welles’ critical profile in America: a very young Peter Bogdanovich, not yet a director, mounted a spectacular retrospective of Welles’s work at the Museum of Modern Art in New York, which bracketed him, still then only in his mid-forties, with the revered grand masters of American cinema – Ford, Hawks and Hitchcock, similarly accorded retrospectives. The Welles exhibition was accompanied by a superbly intelligent essay by Bogdanovich, in which he noted that “in twenty years, Welles has made just seven pictures that can fairly be called his own, but there is a personal unity in his work that can be found in only the greatest poets of the cinema”.
Welles, it appeared, had become a role model for the younger generation of would-be film-makers, as much for what they took to be his defiance of the Hollywood system as for the films themselves. For them, he was a totem of independence and radicalism; they imagined themselves excluded, like him, from Hollywood, punished, as he had been, for their fearless truth-telling. Before long, however, these young Turks began to be courted by Hollywood, while he remained condemned, as far as the establishment was concerned, to a limbo of independent film-making from which, in truth, he never escaped. He was still able to direct films in Europe, among them, in 1962, a severely radical post-Atom Bomb version of Kafka’s The Trial, respectfully received, followed, in 1966, by the film he considered to be his masterpiece, Chimes at Midnight, the latter given short shrift on its first appearance by most British and American critics, with the glowing exception of the influential Pauline Kael, who described him in The New Republic as “the one great creative force in American film in our time.”
This unequivocal approval of hers was not to last long. In 1970, Charles Higham’s pugnacious The Films of Orson Welles had combined serious scholarship with wild and clumsy psychologising, including his coining of the notorious and widely-accepted thesis that Welles suffered from “a fear of completion.” The year after, this was followed by what, for Welles, was a devastating body-blow: Kael’s The Citizen Kane Book – by-line “Kael, Mankiewicz & Welles” – which questioned his authorship of Kane, undermining, on dubious evidence, his one hitherto uncontested claim to greatness. This deeply dismayed him, but did not stop him from ploughing his lonely furrow, frequently acting in films of dubious merit and fronting hammy commercials in order to finance his own work. He became a regular on the chat-show circuit, in the forlorn belief that his appearance on the small screen would remind people of his existence, in turn prompting producers to avail themselves of his services. This did not happen, but he never stopped engendering projects, leaving behind him something in excess of 30 unshot screenplays. Unable to finance his movies, he started to use the camera as a sketchpad for films he intended to make, as often as not shooting in his own house or in some found space – sketches that would perhaps, he hoped, help producers to see the potential of those screenplays.
In what should have been the most productive final twenty years of his life, from the ages of fifty to seventy, he was able to finish only three films, one of them, in 1968, for French television, a severe and powerfully restrained hour-long adaptation of Isak Dinesen’s fable The Immortal Story, his only completed fiction film in colour, another the exuberant essay-film F For Fake, a dazzling, playful and sometimes profound meditation on originality, artifice and deception, ingeniously and wittily combining Welles’s twin passions for conjuring and story-telling. Neither film had any great success on release. Made for German television, the third, Filming Othello, is a semi-documentary account of the shooting of that film; it is at best a mere post-script to it. Meanwhile, over a period of some ten years, he toiled over The Other Side of the Wind, from an initial script co-written by himself and Oja Kodar; it was unlike anything else he had done, sexy, impressionistic, heavily satirical, mocking his fellow directors and indeed himself. Finance, partly from Iranian sources, came and went, the script became ever more fluid, actors were replaced or just disappeared; a number of them died. When he himself shuffled off his mortal coil, the vast quantity of footage remained largely unedited; Welles himself claimed that it was impossible to finish it, which seemed to some commentators to offer conclusive proof of Higham’s thesis about his reluctance to complete.
Meanwhile, two other late projects came tantalisingly close to being realised. The Cradle Will Rock was a project initiated by the producer Michael Fitzgerald, who commissioned Ring Lardner Jr to write a screenplay about the furore surrounding Welles’s 1937 Federal Theatre Project production of Marc Blitzstein’s provocative Agitprop musical of the same name. Fitzgerald then offered the screenplay to Welles to direct. He responded by proposing to write a new screenplay himself which, he said, he would gladly direct; Fitzgerald naturally acceded. Preparations proceeded apace, a vitalised Welles working tirelessly on every aspect of the production until, at the last moment, the principal backer withdrew and the project collapsed. Welles’s screenplay was published after his death, and it proved to possess great charm, freshness and brio, featuring an engaging self-portrait which painted him as perhaps more of an innocent than he was; it seems to suggest a kind of reconciliation with his younger self. The collapse of the project is a deep loss, made somehow sadder by the appearance in 1999 of Cradle Will Rock, Tim Robbins’s abrasive view of the same events, including a severely censorious characterisation of the young Welles.
A second seemingly secure project, King Lear, equally thoroughly prepared, was to have been financed by French television with help from the French government. But Welles rejected their terms, namely that he must stay in France during the entire editing period and would only be paid on completion of the film; deeply offended by both conditions, he walked away from the project. For this Lear there exists no full screenplay, only a set of highly suggestive production designs. Welles spoke eloquently to whoever would listen about the extreme simplicity with which he intended to shoot it, in muted colours and in modern dress, with minimal settings and much use of closeups. There were various attempts to salvage the project, involving among others the British Film Institute and Paul Getty Jr, but they all came to naught. The other project that exercised or, more accurately, obsessed Welles during his last decade was based on Isak Dinesen’s epic story The Dreamers and its later companion piece, Echoes. As a writer, Dinesen was Welles’s idol, for him the supreme story-teller, and he frequently expressed himself unable to think seriously of any other project until he had filmed The Dreamers. He left several extant screenplays for it, all in their different ways filmable; indeed, he shot a number of vividly suggestive sequences in his own house, with Oja Kodar as the endlessly transforming prima donna at the centre of the story. No one he approached for finance could see the commercial potential of the project, nor indeed could anyone see the potential in the would-be crowd-pleasing television programmes – chat shows, magic shows – that he was simultaneously attempting to make.
On an altogether different level of seriousness from the talk show programmes was an exceptional 1982 two-part documentary from the BBC’s Arena programme, from which the present essay has, in an act of hommage, borrowed its title: The Orson Welles Story, a clear-eyed survey of Welles’s life and work. At its heart is a gently probing interview between Welles and the film-maker and film scholar Leslie Megahey, in which Welles, for once not required to perform what he called his “dancing bear routine”, instead speaks with exceptional candour and eloquence about his life in film; it is inevitably melancholy in tone, though his sense of the comedy of life never entirely deserts him, and from time to time he erupts in deep, wheezy chuckles, revealing a great deal of the complexity of this remarkable man. This profoundly revealing document can currently be found available on YouTube.
As it happens, in 1985, only three years after The Orson Welles Story, the critical tide seemed to change with the appearance of Barbara Leaming’s biography, underpinned by, and informed by, her extensive conversations with her subject. The book was in many ways a riposte to both Higham and Kael, a readable and sometimes poignant account of his life and work. Leaming was clearly under Welles’s spell, too easily (if understandably) seduced by his colourful, witty, apparently candid, often fantastical accounts of himself. Welles claimed never to have read the book, but his very last public appearance was, in fact, with Mrs Leaming, on The Merv Griffin Show, on October 9th, 1985, Welles promoting the book, ever hopeful that someone might be stirred by his story and offer him one last chance to direct a film. He went home to continue writing up the notes for his next project – hope springing eternal – and died that night, in harness, at his typewriter.
Exactly as he predicted, he has since been the subject of ceaseless investigation and reassessment. My own biography – especially the first volume of it, The Road to Xanadu, 1995 – could reasonably be described as a belated riposte to Leaming’s, attempting as it did to restore to their proper place the figures that Welles and many of the Wellesians had conveniently forgotten, painting him as the sole creator of all his work in theatre, film and radio, instead of being, as I believed, primus inter pares – certainly in those early days: an inspired improvisor, “presiding” as he later said himself “over accidents.” Later volumes in the series – Hello Americans and One-Man Band – have focussed on the vast range of work he created on stage and film, in the latter medium, particularly, evolving an entirely original approach to shooting and editing. Other writers have been perhaps less concerned with the realities of film-making; before long the semioticians inevitably moved in on Welles, greedily feasting on that substantial corpse, egregiously in Catherine Benamou’s 2007 book about It’s All True, whose text is so minutely and formally analytical as to be virtually impenetrable. Welles, had he tried to read it, would surely have hurled the book across the room. The semioticians seem now, happily, to have withdrawn from the fray, in quest of ever more complex quarry.
There has been no reduction in the flow of biographies. Patrick McGilligan’s Young Orson (2015) is a marvel of fresh research of a kind not possible until the advent of the internet. Many other recent biographies seem to be more about the authors themselves than about Welles. The second and third volumes of my extended biography (2006, 2015), have doggedly tried, in defiance of this trend, to establish the actual process of Welles’ film- and theatre-making, hoping to give a sense of the endlessly contradictory but profoundly creative man behind the work, a real human being, living, breathing, often inspired, sometimes lost, occasionally betrayed – not least by himself. Among the most insightful books about Welles are those by Joseph McBride, the first of which appeared in 1972; a substantial revision appeared more than 25 years later. But even that revised edition had not exhausted McBride’s fascination with his subject, and in 2006, Whatever Happened to Orson Welles? appeared, re-examining earlier judgements but notable above all for the author’s detailed and candid account of his ultimately painful personal engagement with Welles when he was cast in a role in The Other Side of the Wind.
What should have proved to be the most significant contribution to the way we see Welles was the long-awaited This Is Orson Welles, which when it at last appeared in 1992 proved, as with Barbara Leaming’s book, to be very much an exercise in ventriloquism, based on Peter Bogdanovich’s conversations with Welles as preparatory work for the long-promised autobiography he had (more than once) been commissioned to write. Bogdanovich recorded the conversations, transcribed them and handed them to Welles, who rewrote them – both questions and answers. Nonetheless illuminating, highly readable but not entirely reliable, the book was scrupulously edited and annotated by Jonathan Rosenbaum, whose own works on Welles are constantly and precisely insightful, as are those of James Naremore, though both prefer to approach Welles from an analytical and often political perspective, rather than a personal one.
Parallel with this were the ground-breaking activities of Jean-Pierre Berthomé and François Thomas on Welles at work, Esteve Riambau and Juan Cobos on Spanish Welles (this important work is, alas, mostly available only in Spanish) and those of Alberto Anile in his indispensable Orson Welles in Italy, 2013. All of these provided more and more precise and revelatory contexts to Welles’s European activities, which had hitherto been somewhat shadowy. Stefan Drössler of the Munich Filmmuseum provided similarly probing work on the often incomplete, sketch-like work Welles undertook both in Europe and in his later period in Hollywood; he has also painstakingly created a credible assembly of The Deep, a film mysteriously abandoned by Welles when the shoot was very nearly over.
Of a totally different order of illumination, the great bombshell in Welles studies was the sensational discovery – in a warehouse in Pordenone in the Venetian Alps, seventy years after it was shot – of the never-used, long-assumed to be lost footage Welles shot in 1938 for a stage production of William Gillette’s Too Much Johnson. What this material revealed was that Welles, totally untutored in film-making, and with only primitive equipment at his disposal, had an extraordinary eye, his framings epic and perfectly judged in a way that establish beyond doubt that he was a born film director. If Gregg Toland, his cinematographer on Kane, was his tutor, as Welles always maintained, he had a hugely, naturally gifted student.
Meanwhile, a whole new generation of writers and thinkers have started tracking Welles from different perspectives. Matthew Asprey Gear in At the End of the Street in the Shadow reconsiders Welles in the light of his depiction of urban life – his evocation of cities and his embodiment of their variously oppressive characteristics. In other words, he takes Welles very seriously on his own terms, not by trying to force him into a mould of any kind; this approach particularly illuminates Welles as a thinker. A radically different perspective is that of Mark Cousins, a film-maker and documentary-maker himself, whose The Eyes of Orson Welles is a sensuous and intimately personal engagement with Welles’s drawings, paintings and sketches, offering a vivid and tangible sense of Welles’s inner creative life.
An unexpected and indeed unique aspect of Welles’s profile has been his after-life as a character in a large number of films, plays and novels, which have created more or less fantastical versions of the man and in some cases the artist. The novels include The Assassination of Orson Welles, The War of the Worlds Murders, and Big Red, a rollicking romp about Welles and Rita Hayworth, as well as the affectionate Me and Orson Welles, featuring the glory days of the Mercury Theatre on the Air and the triumphant stage production of Julius Caesar; the novel was later made into a very decent film. There have been one-man plays about Welles without number, outstanding among them being Obediently Yours by the pioneer Welles scholar, Richard France. Welles also appears in the wildly inaccurate Orson’s Shadow, a fantasia by Austin Pendleton based on Welles’s London production of Ionesco’s Rhinoceros, which starred Laurence Olivier as Bérenger. There have been two films about the making of Citizen Kane and one – Fade to Black – about that of Othello. Welles also appears, in the shape of Vincent D’Onofrio, as Ed Wood’s ghostly advisor in Tim Burton’s madly idiosyncratic film about the cult B-movie director, while he has what amounts to little more than a walk-on part in David Fincher’s tendentious Mank.
Welles, original in so many ways, is unique in having had one major film – The Other Side of the Wind – completed after his death, and another – Othello – provided with a newly recorded musical score. A modified version of one of his late screenplays – The Big Brass Ring – was filmed posthumously. There also exists a bizarre attempt to right the damage RKO did to The Magnificent Ambersons by reshooting the entire script as originally envisaged by Welles; the result was an entirely predictable catastrophe. Finally, two years after his death, Welles made a poignant appearance in propria persona in Henry Jaglom’s touching Someone to Love. To the dismay of some, Jaglom also authorised a book featuring transcripts of the tapes he made of his luncheon conversations over several years with Welles at Ma Maison restaurant in Los Angeles. The book is harmless enough, consisting mostly of scuttlebutt and ancient grudges; it does little to illuminate Welles’s remarkably complex personality.
There remain, in archives and museums, the remnants of films unfinished – The Deep and, most poignantly, perhaps, Welles’s most personal project, his 20-year quest to tell the story of Don Quixote de la Mancha and his servant Sancho Panza in the modern world; exasperated by endless questions about its progress, he retitled it When Are You Going To Finish Don Quixote? The voluminous material he shot remains scattered across Europe. Wellesophiles are further tantalised by the rumoured existence of an assembly made by Welles himself, secretly coded, then disassembled to protect his vision of the film; the exact whereabouts of all these materials remains unknown. Whether it would ever have been possible even for Welles himself to fashion a coherent film out of the material, given that the young girl who was to have been the interlocutor of Sancho Panza and the Don, was, by the time of Welles’s death, in her late 40’s and both the Quixote and the Sancho Panza had died. An assembly made by the porn-film director Jesús Franco, Welles’s assistant on Chimes at Midnight, is, alas, a travesty of Welles’s intentions. Finally, most tantalising of all, occasional rumours surface of the existence, somewhere in South America, of an answer print of The Magnificent Ambersons containing the scenes so wantonly destroyed by RKO.
The release in 2018 of the completion, under the supervision of Peter Bogdanovich, of The Other Side of the Wind, though a valuable assembly of the material, simply added to its quasi-legendary status as the great might-have-been of Welles’s career. Full of astonishing images and some savage satire of Hollywood – and critics – it fails, over its two hours’ duration, to add up either to a coherent narrative or a fully realised stylistic gesture; it remains an intriguing enigma.
All in all, Welles has more than fulfilled the prophecy he made about his standing after his death: “when I’m gone, they’re gonna love me.” He has certainly provided a banquet for scholars of every persuasion. The film maker with whose trajectory his can perhaps most illuminatingly be compared is one whose work he did not overly admire: Sergei Mikhailovich Eisenstein. Both set new standards for the expressive possibilities of the medium they loved; neither achieved popular acclaim. Both left unfinished work and failed to achieve any kind of commercial success. Both remain puzzles in many ways, personally and artistically; both continue to be beacons for film-makers everywhere, now and in the future.
There is much work still to be done.